Rick noted the government’s filing today in the USPS ballot case, trying to draw the Supreme Court back into the fight. I actually think this one may backfire: the government’s filing is so procedurally odd (you can read flop sweat between the lines on most of the pages), and the underlying rule is so contrary not only to statute but to 252 years of USPS practice, that the Supreme Court is quite likely to sit out this request to stop the litigation – and when it does (and ballots start heading out the door), that will help put an early kibosh on the notion that the Court will respond to rampant wishcasting that they get involved in blatantly illegal misconduct later.
But beyond the overall strategery, a few pieces of the filing seemed notable to me. The Solicitor General (as is increasingly common, it’s just him on the application) is apparently asserting that this rule is:
- Of sufficient national importance to stay a TRO, jumping over both the trial court’s consideration of a PI and any appellate consideration of a stay to either a TRO or a PI, but
- Not of sufficient national importance to raise any major questions questions (despite the lack of meaningful congressional authorization and unprecedented national impact on the election process).
And that the matter is
- Urgent enough to require the Supreme Court’s intervention now now now now before ballots go out tomorrow, but
- Not urgent enough to hold the USPS to any particular timeline on when its procedures might actually be ready for the states to use.
A few years ago, the Chief Justice basically said that the government had to provide at least a veneer of plausibility before the Court would take their claims seriously. Guess we’ll see if that’s still true.
