how do managers feel when their best employee resigns?


A reader writes:

How does it feel to lose one of your best employees?

This is going to be incredibly selfish and self-seeking, so I apologize in advance.

Maybe I’m some sort of psychopath, but at this point I’m truly getting satisfaction fantasizing about resigning. It would be completely out of the blue, and I know they’d be shocked because I truly have fun working there. And I care about doing my best and wanting to help.

However as the saying goes: people don’t quit jobs, they quit people.

I could go on and on of how I’m being treated with a double standard and how the employees who don’t do much are being idolized. Sucking up works.

So I would like to know, when you have that one employee who’s super hard-working, does everything they’re asked to do, never complains, goes above and beyond… and then suddenly with no warning, they resign, does it hurt? Does it bother you? Would it upset you, and if so, how much?

But the job will be done no matter who leaves or stays, so maybe managers could not care less?

There are managers at both ends of the extremes on this — managers who are crushed and managers who don’t care at all — but most managers are somewhere in the middle: disappointed when a good employee leaves but not devastated. They might feel aggravated at the additional work it will mean for them and their team (to hire and train someone new and to cover the work meanwhile), and they might be frustrated that they didn’t have a chance to address whatever drove you to look (if indeed they didn’t; obviously, that’s not always the case).

But most managers also know that everyone leaves their job eventually and it’s a normal thing that happens when you manage people, so most aren’t having the sort of satisfying reaction that I think you’re envisioning.

Occasionally they do! There are managers who are truly shocked when people resign, despite all the things they’ve done to drive them to it.

But generally, even when someone is very disappointed to lose an outstanding employee, the emotional piece of it is fairly fleeting; the hiring and training of someone new pretty quickly becomes just part of the work that manager is handling.

You are better off leaving because it’s the right decision for you, rather than getting caught up in how it will feel to them.

That’s not to say there can’t be a real satisfaction to a well-timed resignation! There can be. (Here’s a particularly satisfying example.) But it shouldn’t drive your decisions.

The post how do managers feel when their best employee resigns? appeared first on Ask a Manager.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Daily Deals
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart