Defeating Death – by William C. Green


AI generated image

Image source: Shutterstock

In a familiar Christian telling, death enters the world through sin and is defeated through the crucifixion and bodily resurrection of Jesus Christ.

Some people would rather not wait for resurrection.

In a 2005 TED Talk, longevity researcher Aubrey de Grey argued that we could overcome aging. He proposed that people already alive could live to 1,000, with successive treatments repairing the damage that would otherwise kill them. Each treatment would keep us alive long enough for better treatments to come along.

The technologies are new. The wish to live forever without first having to die is ancient. That wish takes technological as well as religious forms.

Transhumanism, the view that technology can extend human capacities beyond their biological limits, encompasses much more than longevity. A movement calling itself “Vitalism” makes defeating aging and death its overriding priority. As one advocate puts it, “Can we just solve this death thing first?”

Meanwhile, one app estimates how many days you have left to live. Another promises a digital version of you that can keep talking after you’re dead.

Of course. Then we can get around to the minor business of deciding what life is for.

There is nothing trivial about preventing dementia, relieving pain, or gaining another year with someone you love. Those aims already tell us something about what makes life worth prolonging.

In Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud described technological humanity as a “prosthetic God,” equipped with powers that had not made it happy. We already depend on technology for much of the life we hope to prolong. The question is what that dependence makes possible, whom it serves, and what purposes it leaves us free to pursue.

Extending life cannot relieve us of deciding how to live it. The wish to outlast death also leads us to look for something larger than ourselves. A cause promises that our lives will count after they end. The danger begins when the promise of lasting significance buys our loyalty at the expense of our judgment.

A life need not last forever to count. For thinkers as different as Epicurus and physicist Sean Carroll, death ends the person, but that need not diminish a life’s meaning.

Christian resurrection hope refuses to accept death as final. It promises something more than an indefinite extension of life. The risen Christ still bears the wounds of a love he would not abandon to save himself. Resurrection vindicates that love; it does not make self-preservation the purpose of life. To flourish is to love in ways that make God’s presence known.

On this understanding, eternal life begins within the life we want to prolong. A shared meal, a friendship, an act of forgiveness can bring us into communion with God and one another. Their worth exceeds their duration. The promise of resurrection is that such communion will become the fullness of life, with nothing left to estrange us from God or anyone else.

That hope asks more than the indefinite survival of the person I am. Some of what I cling to must go.

In “The Consuming Fire,” George MacDonald writes, “Therefore all that is not beautiful in the beloved, all that comes between and is not of love’s kind, must be destroyed.” God’s love will not abandon the beloved to whatever keeps love out.

Gustav Mahler gives resurrection hope a voice in the finale of his Second Symphony. After the orchestra’s upheavals, the chorus enters at the edge of audibility. By the close, voices, brass, bells, and organ have joined in an affirmation that death itself will be overcome. “Prepare yourself to live,” it sings. After so much talk of postponing the end, the music asks us to imagine the beginning.

Listen to an excerpt from the finale, performed by the Berlin Philharmonic, with an introduction by Sir Simon Rattle.

Or hear that joy in a very different musical language with the Edwin Hawkins Singers’ “Oh Happy Day.”

Neither suffering nor death gets to say everything about being alive. That conviction has a secular voice, too. In “Return to Tipasa,” Albert Camus writes, “In the depths of winter, I finally learned that within me there lay an invincible summer.”

Jack Gilbert puts the refusal more sharply in “A Brief for the Defense.” “To make injustice the only measure of our attention is to praise the Devil.” A few lines later, “We must admit there will be music despite everything.”

Faith begins in gratitude and humility, in praise and prayer before it finds words for belief. Its hope rests on a promise. The enemy that has taken everyone we could not bear to lose will, in turn, be lost.

Death dies. Prepare yourself to live.

Notes and reading

Longevity and its purposes — Nicolai Wohns and Daniel Promislow, “Lessons for Responsible Geroscience From the History of Longevity,” AMA Journal of Ethics (December 2025). A historical perspective on life extension that keeps equitable access and social responsibility in view.

Already posthuman — Nathan Gardels, “We Are Already Post-Human,” Noema (October 9, 2026). On computational systems that modern societies depend on for survival. Without them, the lights would go out. The task is to preserve embodied human judgment within that dependence.

Living with AI — Ethan Mollick, Co-Existence: The Next Phase of AI (2026). The Wharton professor considers how to work with increasingly capable AI while retaining human judgment and agency.

Materialisms, new and old — Epicurus’s “Letter to Herodotus” explains the soul’s material nature; Sean Carroll’s The Big Picture (2016) offers a contemporary account of life, consciousness, and meaning within a physical universe.

Death Is Not Final — Closing statements from a 2014 debate featuring Eben Alexander, Steven Novella, Raymond Moody, and Sean Carroll, prominent physicians, scientists, and authors whose work explores consciousness, death, and the possibility of an afterlife. YouTube.

Resurrection and human worth — Rowan Williams, “Easter Day Sermon” (Canterbury Cathedral, April 11, 2004). Resurrection as God’s refusal to let violence and death extinguish human worth or consign their victims to oblivion.

Edwin Hawkins Singers — Pioneers of contemporary gospel whose “Oh Happy Day” became an international hit and won a Grammy.

Literary sources — Albert Camus, “Return to Tipasa,” in Lyrical and Critical Essays, translated by Ellen Conroy Kennedy and edited by Philip Thody (1968); Jack Gilbert, “A Brief for the Defense,” in Refusing Heaven (2005).

Subject to Approval

Unknown Advantage

About 2 + 2 = 5

Editorial note: I sometimes use AI-assisted tools for proofreading, clarification, and revision. The ideas, judgments, and final wording remain my own.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Daily Deals
Logo
Register New Account
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0
Shopping cart